Reactogenicity
and immunogenicity of a combined measles, mumps, rubella (MMR) and
varicella (V) vaccine, compared to concomitant injections of MMR+V in
healthy children aged 12-24 months
Zepp F.1,
and Steens J-M.2
1Johannes Gutenberg Universität,
Mainz, Germany; 2GlaxoSmithKline, Rixensart,
Belgium
Objective. A tetravalent MMRV vaccine would facilitate the
implementation of universal immunization against varicella in early
childhood. This study was designed to assess reactogenicity and
immunogenicity of a combined tetravalent measles, mumps, rubella and
varicella (MMRV) vaccine, compared with MMR+V vaccines administered
concomitantly.
Methods. 556 healthy children (12-24 months) were
randomised into two groups (ratio 2:1) to receive subcutaneously a single
dose of either MMRV, or MMR (PriorixŌ) + V (VarilrixŌ) GSK’s vaccines. Local symptoms were
recorded for 4 days after vaccination. General adverse events (fever, rash,
parotid and/or salivary gland swelling, signs of meningism, febrile
convulsions) were noted for 42 days. Serum samples were taken before
vaccination and 42 days after. Anti-MMR antibodies were measured by ELISA
(cut-offs: measles, 150 IU/ml; mumps, 4 IU/ml; rubella, 231 IU/ml).
Varicella antibodies titers were determined using immunofluorescence assay
(cut-off: 1:4).
Results. Incidence of solicited local reactions for MMRV and MMR+V were
respectively: 24.8% and 26.9% for redness, 7.1% and 6.6% for swelling, 9.5%
and 9.9% for pain. One case of parotid gland swelling was recorded in each
group. Generalised rash was observed in 19.9% (MMRV) and 14.8% (MMR+V) of
subjects, with decreasing frequencies from the third week after
vaccination. Cumulative incidences of rectal temperatures >38.0°C, >39.5°C, and >40°C were 60.5% and 54.9%, 18.3% and 13.7%, and
5.2% and 6.6% for MMRV and MMR+V groups respectively. Four SAEs were
recorded (3 for MMRV group and 1 for MMR+V group) and defined as
coincidentally associated with vaccination. Post-vaccination immunological
data are summarized below (% seroconverted subjects and GMTs):
Group
|
Measles
|
Mumps
|
Rubella
|
Varicella
|
%
|
GMT
|
%
|
GMT
|
%
|
GMT
|
%
|
GMT
|
MMRV
|
98.7
|
3807
|
95.7
|
1968
|
96.7
|
43
|
98.0
|
188
|
MMR+V
|
99.3
|
2548
|
97.2
|
1674
|
100
|
51
|
100
|
299
|
Conclusions. Immunogenic responses and
local reactions to MMRV and MMR+V vaccines were similar. Considering the
advantages of a single over two injections the increase in fever
(>39,5°C) observed with MMRV was rated as clinically acceptable.