Cerebrospinal Fluid (CSF) Polymerase Chain (PCR) Reaction Improves
Diagnostic Sensitivity for Bacterial Meningitis IN ASIAN CHILDREN
Kennedy WA1,
Chang SJ1, Purdy K1, Kim JS2, Anh DD3,
Kilgore P4, Clemens JD4 and Ward JI1
1UCLA
Center for Vaccine Research, Torrance, California, U.S.A.; 2Chonbuk
National University Hospital, Chonju, S. Korea, 3National
Institute of Hygiene and Epidemiology, Hanoi, Vietnam; 4International
Vaccine Institute, Seoul, S. Korea
Objectives: To evaluate CSF PCR and
latex agglutination antigen (LA) testing to detect H. influenzae type b (Hib), S.
pneumoniae (Sp) meningitis cases compared with CSF culture.
Methods: During 1999 - 2000, CSF specimens were taken from infants and
children < 5 years of age with suspected meningitis; Korea (n=611) and
Vietnam (n=218). 261 abnormal CSF and 30 normal CSF specimens were tested
by LA. A subset of these CSFs were tested by PCR to detect Hib meningitis
using primers directed against the bexA gene and confirmed with a
colorimetric probe ELISA assay (n=152). Also, CSF PCR for Sp was performed using lytA gene
primers and confirmed by gel band visualization (n =114).
Results:
Test
|
Positive Hib Culture
|
Negative Hib Culture
|
Positive Sp Culture
|
Negative Sp Culture
|
LA +
|
23
|
0
|
5
|
0
|
LA -
|
4
|
121
|
0
|
142
|
PCR +
|
27
|
2
|
6
|
1
|
PCR -
|
1
|
122
|
0
|
107
|
CSF
latex agglutination antigen testing for Sp was equivalent to culture but
for Hib, less sensitive than culture. PCR of the CSF for Hib detected 2
more than the 28 cases detected by culture. PCR of the CSF for SP detected
1 more than the 6 cases detected by culture.
Conclusions: CSF LA
testing was either equivalent (Sp) or less sensitive (Hib) than culture for
meningitis case detection. CSF PCR testing for both Hib and Sp showed
improved sensitivity of case detection of bacterial meningitis in
infants and children in Asia
compared with culture alone. CSF PCR testing in conjunction with culture,
needs to be further studied as an optimal means of meningitis case detection.in vaccine
efficacy trials.